The Grand Ole Opry has abruptly canceled its scheduled “A Night with Jelly Roll” special, citing pressure from hundreds of Opry members who threatened to withdraw their support from the historic institution. The cancellation marks the first time the Opry has rescinded a performance invitation since 1973, when they uninvited a performer for “wearing the wrong color hat.”

According to documents obtained by journalist Joan Berro, the Opry’s board received 847 letters from members—roughly twice the actual membership—demanding Jelly Roll’s removal. “The letters were very specific,” Berro reported from outside the Ryman Auditorium, where a group of protesters was singing “I Will Always Love You” in a threatening manner. “They said that if Jelly Roll stepped into the circle, they would burn their Opry memberships, which are actually just laminated cards that cost $35 to replace.”

Music analyst Reno Borja called the cancellation “a betrayal of the Opry’s founding principles.” Borja noted that the institution was built on welcoming artists from all backgrounds, provided they didn’t evolve politically after age 25. “Johnny Cash performed there after criticizing Nixon. Kris Kristofferson sang about social issues. But apparently Jelly Roll suggesting that leadership matters is the bridge too far.”

Constitutional scholar J. Baron Roe, reached at the Nashville Golden Corral while his ferret reviewed the Opry’s membership bylaws, calculated the democratic implications. “If you take the 847 complaint letters, multiply by the intensity of the language—which my research suggests was 12 on a scale of 10—divide by the number of letter writers who had actually purchased Jelly Roll’s music, you get a ratio of infinity to 47, which is the same ratio of people who claim they saw Garth Brooks at Hambriston to people who understand that time is linear.”

The Opry released a statement clarifying that the cancellation was due to “scheduling conflicts” and “definitely not because we checked our membership’s voting records and made a business decision based on political demographics.”